A chocolate chip cookie article and Spring Break in NYC led to a self-guided NYC Chocolate Chip Cookie Tour. Finding the best chocolate chip cookie in Manhattan sounded like just the way to spend my week. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/09/dining/09chip.html?_r=3
The City Bakery: A large cookie that had a strong taste of butter and brown sugar. Somewhat chewy with large chocolate chunks. A good cookie but a little too rich for my taste. I was disappointed because the cookie appeared to be on a warmer, but it was at room temperature when I got it. I also tried the hot chocolate here since it was supposed to be the best. It was very thick — like melted chocolate with a little bit of heavy cream in it. I also got a peanut butter cookie here. It was a small mound and it was very light, soft, and crumbly, like the flour was sifted well. The peanut butter cookie was great, but overall I would not make the trip back there. Especially with Max Brenner just around the corner. http://thecitybakery.com/
Milk and Cookies: Such a cute little shop! It was all homey and cute just like a milk and cookies place should be. It had maybe a dozen different types of cookies. I had the chocolate chip and peanut butter. These were smaller (or normal) size cookies. The chocolate chip was crunchy and had good texture – maybe with ground nuts? The peanut butter had peanut butter chips in it (my favorite!). It actually reminded me a lot of Diddy Reese in Westwood, CA. Better because the cookies are actually good and made with quality ingredients. Worse because they don’t have $1 cookie ice cream sandwiches. Overall, it was a great experience and I will go back again the next time I’m in Greenwich Village. http://www.milkandcookiesbakery.com/
Jacques Torres: The hands down winner! This shop is out of the way in a somewhat industrial area, but we made the walk from Greenwich Village. It’s a pretty big chocolate shop. We got to see them making all their easter bunnies from behind the glass. Supposedly, they grind the chocolate there from the beans, although I didn’t get to see that. They asked me if I wanted the cookie warm and got it from a warmer. The large cookie was a perfect blend of chewy outside and soft middle with delicious melty chocolate. The chocolate was clearly of good quality, also.http://www.mrchocolate.com/
Max Brenner: This was my runner up favorite. I got a dark cookie since their regular chocolate chip came with milk chocolate. The dark cookie is a chocolate cookie with semisweet chocolate chips. It was a large, thick cookie — chewy/crisp on the outside and soft and almost brownie-like in the middle. I got the cookie and left, but it was a cute restaurant atmosphere with lots of chocolate options. http://www.maxbrenner.com/
/

